Hi Sissy,
You and your questions are very welcome here. I know you love your sister very much and just want her to be as well as possible. Is surgery her answer? I don't know. I would have to know more about her medical situation. You are very upfront and so am I. I have a medical background and have studied Cranial Nerve Disorders and CM's since 10/ 2004. I became very ill in 7/2001. I have also read every study and peer review and know most of the specialists who wrote them.
I disagree that surgery is the answer in 99% of cases or a cure and tell everyone. I have talked to 1,000's of Chiarians and only told two I thought they should have surgery. I am almost 8 years post op and wouldn't wish my life on anyone. I was diagnosed too late and almost became a quadripledgic. My surgeries were 16 hours long and they had to rebuild my C Spine. I recommend everyone see a Great NS not a NS at a Chiari Center unless they have another underlying condition. Then I recommend one NS at a Chiari Center.
I think what you need to realize is that many people come here and have a diminished quality of life and bad symptoms. They think and are at times told that surgery will heal them and or they will get their life back. You have read the statistics you and I both know that is nearly always impossible. They may have a positive surgical experience but within two years start having post op symptoms. They symptoms might be their pre op symptoms returning or new symptoms. They are still horrible and these people suffer. Children with CM die daily. Adults die but not as often.
My surgery was considered a success because I am not a quadripledgic. It doesn't matter I feel like my head is bolted on 24/7 or I am in constant severe chronic pain. That my whole life disappeared as so many does along with most of my friends because they can't watch or be there when I can't literally & figuratively. That I have had to make plans for my daughter three times in case I was no longer here. Then there are the countless other horrible symptoms, side effects, treatments, therapies and related disorder I also endure.
Why do intelligent people still opt for a flawed surgery on an illness no one 100% understands?....... Hope. Hope that they will get their lives back and themselves back. If only for a month or a year or however long they are fortunate enough to feel well. On rare cases I know people that feel well for years. Do you know what I would give for a day or a week or an hour? In the morning if I don't move for a few seconds I feel normal. Then I blink my eyes and it disappears and reality floods in.
I have seen hearing restored in a teenager, who even though she is having post op issues is still glad she had the surgery. She has a huge part of her life back. She can hear. That is a Miracle.
All the Dr's we recommend or others have turndown 98% of patients for surgery. Most take the "Wait and See" approach unless there is a Major Herniation or CSF Blockage, or Syringomyelia, or Tethered Cord, or other severe medical situations.
I usually am not so negative because it terrifies Members especially New Members just diagnosed. So do we terrify everyone or answer their questions and send them to a qualified Physician when asked? I do not lie to anyone. If asked I will tell them the truth as I have you. So do not quote Neurology Journals to me. Do you even know that I personally was in the hospital week before last and had a 20+ year practicing Neurologist tell me she knew nothing about Chiari , that she specialized in Epilepsy & was sorry my NL was on vacation. Do you know every time we break down and go to the ER that 99% of the time they have never even heard of Chiari or know what to do with us. How dare you come here and start preaching to us about "sites like this" until you get to know Chiarians and this site. Do not assume just because we have Chiari we aren't educated or well connected or aren't good personal medical advocates.
The patients are the experts.
The Specialists need to be educated. The ones we recommend actually are.
Now I am truly sorry your sister may have CM. I hope she doesn't, but by being condescending to people that can help you and her is not a good start.
Was your post to make us aware that surgery sucks and our life is crap? Or is it that you are afraid? We were all afraid as was our loved ones.
Everyone here is actually a Hero.....because even against the odds they still chose & choose to fight and hold out Hope.
Not to be rude as you have, but maybe you should let your sister get a consultation and a second and third opinion, then respect her wishes and support her. This is not an easy Journey, but one you can live through.
No one here chose this life. We just try to make the best of it and play the cards we're dealt.
Tracy Z.